Every business policy is built on the information you give the insurer before it starts, and again each time it renews or changes. That obligation is the duty of disclosure. Insurance law treats business and consumer policies differently here, and the difference can matter when a claim is assessed. This guide explains the general position for commercial business insurance in plain terms. It is general information, not legal advice: your policy documents contain the disclosure notice that applies to you, so check your policy and get legal or professional advice on anything specific.
Duty of Disclosure Insurance Rules: Business vs Consumer
Australian insurance contracts law, principally the Insurance Contracts Act 1984, sets out two different obligations depending on the kind of policy.
- Business policies: the duty of disclosure. For policies taken out for business purposes, you generally have a duty to tell the insurer anything you know, or that a reasonable person in your circumstances could be expected to know, is relevant to the insurer’s decision about whether to accept the risk and on what terms.
- Consumer policies: a duty to take reasonable care. Following reforms in recent years, policies taken out wholly or mainly for personal, domestic or household purposes generally carry a different obligation: to take reasonable care not to make a misrepresentation when answering the insurer’s questions.
The practical difference is who frames the questions. Under the consumer duty, the insurer’s questions largely set the boundaries of what you need to tell them. Under the business duty, you may be expected to volunteer relevant matters even when nobody asks.
Which Policies Fall on Which Side?
The answer generally depends on why the policy was taken out, not on who you are. A sole trader’s home and contents policy, or a car used mainly for private purposes, may fall under the consumer rules. A business package, liability, plant, fleet or commercial property policy will generally sit under the duty of disclosure.
Some cases are less clear, such as a ute used for both work and family, or a policy held in the name of a family trust or company. Where it is unclear, ask your broker how the policy is being treated, and get advice if the answer affects a claim.
What Counts as Relevant
There is no complete list, because relevance depends on the risk being insured. For business policies, the kinds of matters insurers generally treat as relevant include:
- Claims and losses history, including incidents that did not lead to a claim and claims made against you by others.
- Insurance history, such as a policy that was declined, cancelled, not renewed or issued with special terms.
- Criminal convictions or insolvency involving the business or the people who run it.
- What the business actually does, including side activities, occasional work and work done through subcontractors. Our article on why the occupation matters on liability insurance explains why the description carries so much weight.
- How vehicles and plant are used: who drives or operates, where they go, and whether you carry goods for others. Our post on hire and reward versus private use shows how the declared use can shape a claim.
- Driver matters, such as licence suspensions, infringements and defect notices. See how infringements and defect notices affect truck insurance.
- The condition of property: construction, vacancy, renovation, fire protection, security and known defects.
Disclosure notices generally say you do not need to tell the insurer about matters that reduce the risk, matters of common knowledge, matters the insurer knows or should know in the ordinary course of its business, or matters the insurer has said it does not need to know. The exact wording is in the notice in your proposal or policy documents, and that is the version to read.
When the Duty Applies
The duty generally applies before you enter into a policy, and again before you renew, extend, vary or reinstate it. Renewal is where problems commonly start. A business changes over a year: a new type of work, a new site, a bigger truck, a subcontractor who becomes an employee, a claim made against you since the last renewal. If the renewal goes through on last year’s information, the policy may no longer match the business.
Policies can also include conditions requiring you to notify certain changes during the policy period, such as a building becoming vacant or a change in how a vehicle is used. That is a contractual obligation separate from the duty of disclosure, and it can run all year. Check your wording.
What Can Happen if Something Is Not Disclosed
The consequences depend on what was not disclosed, whether it would have changed the insurer’s decision, and whether the failure was innocent or fraudulent. In general terms, and depending on the circumstances and the policy:
- the insurer may be able to reduce a claim to the amount it would have paid if it had been told, which can mean nothing if it would not have offered cover at all;
- the insurer may be able to cancel the policy;
- where non-disclosure was fraudulent, the insurer may be able to avoid the policy altogether, treating it as though it never existed.
These are legal questions that turn on the facts and the wording. If an insurer raises non-disclosure on a claim, involve your broker straight away and get legal advice before you respond.
Practical Ways to Get Disclosure Right
- Read the proposal as it will be submitted. Check every answer, including any carried over from last year.
- When in doubt, disclose. Telling the insurer something it did not need costs little. Leaving out something it did need can cost a claim.
- Describe the whole business, including side activities and occasional work.
- Keep a disclosure record: a copy of the proposal and the emails confirming what was sent and when.
- Put changes in writing during the year, not only in a phone call.
- Start renewals early. Review turnover, wages, assets, vehicles, contracts and claims well before the renewal date, not the day before it lapses.
Where a Broker Helps
A broker asks the questions an underwriter would ask, knows which matters insurers tend to treat as relevant in your industry, and presents the information clearly. That is one of the practical reasons to use an insurance intermediary. The duty still rests with you, though. A broker can only pass on what you tell them, so treat the broker conversation as the disclosure conversation, and check that what you said made it into the submission.
If you move your business insurance to a new insurer, the duty applies to the new policy, so past claims, incidents and insurance history need to be disclosed again.
Common Questions
Do I have to disclose a claim paid by a different insurer?
Generally yes, if it is relevant to the risk being insured. Claims history is one of the first things underwriters look at, whichever insurer paid.
What if the insurer never asked the question?
Under a business policy, the duty of disclosure is generally not limited to the questions asked. If a reasonable person in your position would know a matter was relevant, it may need to be disclosed anyway. If you are unsure, ask your broker or get advice.
Does the duty end once the policy starts?
The duty generally applies before a policy is entered into, renewed, varied, extended or reinstated. Separate policy conditions may require you to notify certain changes during the year, so check your policy.
Talk It Through
Request a quote or call 1300 983 940 and we will go through what your insurer is likely to need to know before your next renewal. For a legal question about a specific claim or disclosure issue, speak to a lawyer.
General advice only. This article does not take your objectives, financial situation or needs into account. Consider the relevant PDS and Target Market Determination before deciding on a policy.